Holiday Crime Isn’t “Nighttime Crime.” That Myth Gets People Hurt (and Keeps SOCs Busy)

  • Property crime isn’t automatically “night.” Residential burglary often happens during work hours. UCR+1

  • Business-focused crime skews more night (especially non-residential burglary). UCR

  • Violence often clusters late-day/evening (and youth violence is commonly after-school). ojjdp.gov

So if you’re doing RVM/SOC planning: after-hours coverage is necessary, but “after-hours only” is a strategy bug, not a strategy.

3 minutes read
Close-up of a gloved hand prying open a door at night outside a holiday-decorated home, with blurred Christmas lights and a wrapped package on snowy ground—dramatic, high-contrast scene suggesting “holiday risk” and hidden threats

From all of us at ArcadianAI: we hope you and your team have a safe, calm holiday season.

Now the uncomfortable truth:

The holidays don’t just “increase crime.” They scramble routines — and that changes when crime happens. If you only tighten security “after-hours,” you’re protecting the wrong hours for a big chunk of real-world risk.

The timing trap: “Crime = night” is a lazy assumption

1) Burglary timing flips depending on what you’re protecting

The FBI’s national burglary breakdown uses Day = 6am–6pm and Night = 6pm–6am. (Federal Bureau of Investigation)

In the U.S. (2019):

  • Residential burglary (dwelling):
    Day: 354,398 vs Night: 238,635 (Unknown: 109,415) (Federal Bureau of Investigation)
    → Homes get hit a lot in the day.

  • Non-residential burglary (store/office/etc.):
    Night: 191,663 vs Day: 152,956 (Unknown: 70,629) (Federal Bureau of Investigation)
    → Businesses skew more night.

Holiday implication: When people travel, shop, and change schedules, the “easy hours” shift. Empty home mid-day + distracted evenings = opportunity.

2) Robbery and assault lean later — but not always “midnight”

BJS (NCVS tables) shows nighttime dominance for more weapon-involved incidents. Example (1999 table):

  • Armed robbery: 70.4% nighttime

  • Unarmed robbery: 39.9% nighttime

  • Armed assault: 52.4% nighttime

  • Unarmed assault: 38.9% nighttime (Bureau of Justice Statistics)

Holiday implication: Crowds, retail hours, parties, and late-day foot traffic increase the “evening risk window,” not just 2am.

3) Youth vs adult violence spikes at totally different hours

OJJDP’s national pattern is blunt:

  • Youth violent crime: 37% occurs between noon and 5pm

  • Adult violent crime: 30% occurs between 6pm and 11pm (ojjdp.gov)

Holiday implication: If you run schools/community sites, retail near transit, malls, or multi-residential common areas, the after-school/afternoon window matters even in winter.

“But it’s the holidays — what crimes actually surge?”

The holidays amplify opportunity crimes:

Package theft is a modern holiday sport (sadly)

A U.S. Postal Service OIG report estimates at least 58 million packages stolen in 2024, with up to $16B in reported losses. (Office of Inspector General)

And yes, multi-residential properties get hammered (lobbies, mailrooms, hallways) — because the thief doesn’t need to “break in.” They just need a blind spot and 15 seconds.

Retail theft pressure rises when shopping volume peaks

NRF expects U.S. holiday sales to surpass $1 trillion for the first time in 2025. (National Retail Federation)
More volume = more chaos = more opportunity.

NRF also reports retailers saw an 18% increase in average shoplifting incidents in 2024 vs 2023, and threats/acts of violence during shoplifting/theft events rose 17%. (National Retail Federation)

Translation: the “small theft” problem increasingly becomes a safety problem.

The ArcadianAI warning (and why we’re saying this now)

If your holiday security plan is basically:

“We’ll watch after-hours harder.”

…you’re walking into the exact trap the data highlights:

Security isn’t “a night shift problem.” It’s a timing + context problem.

A practical holiday safety playbook (homes, multi-residential, retail)

Homeowners & employees (simple, high-leverage)

  • Kill the “visible target”: don’t leave boxes/gifts visible through windows (yes, people notice).

  • Make delivery theft hard: use pickup lockers / signature options / workplace delivery when possible.

  • Don’t broadcast absence: avoid real-time travel posts; post later.

  • Lights + consistency: timers beat “random manual lights.”

Multi-residential / property managers (highest ROI actions)

  • Treat mailrooms like cash drawers: they need the same seriousness as retail stockrooms.

  • Reduce tailgating: signage + door hardware + resident education.

  • Aim cameras at decision points (entrances, elevator lobbies, mailroom door) not just “wide shots.”

  • Operational response matters: if nobody reviews footage or responds, cameras are theater.

Retail operators (what actually changes outcomes)

  • Shift attention to the “edges”: entrances, high-value aisles, self-checkout, returns desk.

  • Build for surges: your worst day is not average — it’s the Saturday before Christmas.

  • Prioritize staff safety: NRF’s violence trend is a warning, not a footnote. (National Retail Federation)

Where ArcadianAI fits (without the hype)

ArcadianAI exists for one reason:

Make video monitoring workable under real-world constraints — noise, fatigue, staffing limits, and seasonal spikes.

Ranger is designed to:

  • Filter motion chaos into verified, usable alarms

  • Reduce operator overload

  • Support after-hours and daytime risk windows (because the data says both matter)

If you’re running a SOC, guard company, RVM operation, or managing multi-site properties: this is the season where false alarms and missed real events become painfully expensive.

Closing: a real holiday message

We genuinely hope nothing happens to you, your people, or your property.

But hoping isn’t a security strategy.

So here’s our ask: audit your “crime happens at night” assumption before it audits you.

Security is like insurance—until you need it, you don’t think about it.

But when something goes wrong? Break-ins, theft, liability claims—suddenly, it’s all you think about.

ArcadianAI upgrades your security to the AI era—no new hardware, no sky-high costs, just smart protection that works.
→ Stop security incidents before they happen 
→ Cut security costs without cutting corners 
→ Run your business without the worry
Because the best security isn’t reactive—it’s proactive. 

Is your security keeping up with the AI era? Book a free demo today.